If there’s no clear red flag, yes. A first date is surface-level by nature, and most real connections (friendships included) take more than one meeting to figure out. Only rule someone out immediately if something was actually off.
Summary
In this episode of “How to Twenty-Something,” I dive into the complex realm of online dating and share my thoughts and experiences on dating apps like Bumble, Tinder, and Hinge. This episode aims to shift the mindset around online dating, encouraging listeners to embrace it with a positive and open-minded approach while also acknowledging its challenges. I highlight the importance of self-awareness, mental health, and setting clear intentions before diving into the world of online dating. By celebrating small successes and maintaining a growth mindset, the journey of finding love or meaningful connections becomes more manageable.
Key Takeaways:
- The struggles of dating in your twenties and the challenges of finding suitable partners
- The psychological impact of having too many options on dating apps and what to do about it
- Tips for creating an effective and genuine dating profile and what to avoid
- Emphasizing safety precautions when meeting someone from a dating app
What makes a good vs. bad dating app profile?
Clear, smiling, solo photos without sunglasses or hats, and a bio that gives a little personality and something to talk about. Avoid oversharing red flags upfront (like “I drink too much”) or leaving zero personality on the page, both scare off a real first impression.
Should I give someone a second date if I'm not sure how I feel after the first one?
Should I keep talking to other people on dating apps once I've matched with someone I like?
It depends on your attachment style. If you tend toward anxious attachment, spreading your attention across a few conversations can actually keep you from spiraling over one person’s response time. Once things become official, that’s when you pull your profile and stop dating other people.
Related Episodes
Ep. 96 Online Dating vs Organic Dating
Ep. 21 Dating in Your Twenties
Ep. 104 What ghosting really means
Ep. 27 Everyone’s in love, but you with Lucy Price
Ep. 117 In Your Single Era with Danielle Facchine
Transcript
The wonderful world of online dating
Welcome back to how to twenty-something, today i’m going to talk to you about the wonderful world of online dating and how to change your mentality around it
While also trying to convince myself to view it better
Because yes I was being sarcastic when titling this episode
If you know me then you know I hate online dating, the apps feel so superficial and then you get all caught up in decision fatigue because you could be talking to a great human being but then think wait what if this person is better
And as a result you continue to end up alone all because you keep thinking of what else could be out there
Honestly, I think guys should listen to this episode the most because your profiles are god awful
The pictures you choose are blurry, the prompts you write, if you even write prompts, give us nothing to work with, and you willingly throw all your red flags into your profile when it should be your best foot forward
And unfortunately for you, it might already be your best foot forward
I’ve been trying to improve my dating life this year, it was part of my new year’s resolution to go on one date a month, organically, so without the use of the apps
And I failed miserably from January through April and then in May I asked out a guy I thought was a suitable bachelor and he friend zoned me, so my Sunday Scaries, post terrible coffee date, that wasn’t actually a date, led me to downloading bumble
And oh my goodness it’s worse than I expected, when I already had very low expectations set
Which is why I feel called to make an episode about dating apps, so here we are
First off, I know dating apps have a success rate, my sister and her fiance met on bumble, my friends who have been married for four years met on tinder, my friend and her boyfriend met on tinder, my other friend and her fiance met on hinge, and even another friend just became official with her boyfriend and they met on bumble
So yes, there is proof that it does work, but there is also so much more proof of it not working at all and being a very frustrating process
And hopefully by the end of this episode you and I will both feel differently about the dating apps and the world of online dating, because trust me when I say I’m right here with you.. It’s rough out there
Dating in your twenties is already tough, people are moving around, trying to figure their own life out, not ready settle down, filled with trauma from their last relationship, and are still growing as a person and not really sure what they’re looking for
And I made an episode on dating in your twenties a long time ago, but this one is specifically about dating online and is to help shift your mindset going into it and the way you are experiencing it
I will say, living in a city does keep the people younger longer and what I mean by that is city life promotes the single bachelor life with multiple girls around, late nights at the bars, and college culture extended into adulthood
Making it even harder to find someone suitable for you
Now, online dating has been around for a long time, I remember as a kid my mom would be on Jdate, or on tv you would see a commercial for christian singles, I think there was even a platform for farmers, there was eharmony, and match.com
So online dating was around well before what we know it as today with the three primary ones now being tinder, bumble, and hinge
And I can’t really speak as to whether or not things have shifted from the creation of the different platforms, but I am going to focus on primarily bumble and hinge for the purpose of this episode and within that the heterosexual side of dating apps as I can’t personally speak to the LGBTQ community
The stereotypes of these primary apps are tinder is the hookup app, hinge is the nice one that’s the most helpful, and bumble is the safest because the girl has to make the first move
Although now even that part has changed because you can add an opening prompt to your profile that let’s the guy message first
Up until now, I’ve only had one guy message me first and he’s actually the only bumble date I’ve gone on.. It helped that i recognized him from the gym when i came across his profile so I knew he wasn’t a complete psychopath and had a great taste in gyms
But i think the biggest problem dating apps create from a psychological perspective is the too many options
It’s hard to settle down when there’s always going to be the potential to swipe right and match with someone new and possibly better
I ask a few of my friends their opinions on dating apps, their mindset around it, tricks or tips they’ve learned along the way, and really anything that would help me with the topic of this episode and one of my guy friends mentioned that when he has a date on the calendar with a girl he pauses his profile so he’s not tempted to continue swiping
He’s helping his brain focus on one thing at a time and see where it goes and doesn’t want to keep distracting himself with the bigger better offer that could present itself with one more profile
I told him that I liked that idea but that I’m also reading the book attached and it says that if you have an anxious attachment style it is actually more beneficial for you to continue to schedule dates with other people even when you’ve found someone you like
Simply because it helps you brain not focus on that one person and whether they have responded to your message yet or not
So it calms your attachment system in the form of a healthy distraction and not letting you put all of your eggs in that one basket
Now, of course, when things become official or more serious between you two then yes remove your profile and stop going on other dates
But when you’re still within the first month of seeing one another, and you know you are an anxious person, then continue to put yourself out there
So it’s really knowing what’s going to work best for you based on your own tendencies
I know I get really anxious so it would be better for me to keep my options open and not pause my profile, but maybe you are someone like my guy friend who does need to do so
Another aspect of the dating apps is you are meeting a complete stranger from the internet and that’s not something you should forget
From a safety standpoint, your first date should be in public, in the day time, preferably an activity, and your friends should know where you’re going
I say it should be an activity because moving your body around and having something else to do will help with conversations and with any awkwardness or first date jitters
This could entail going for a walk, or mini-golfing, even top golf, or pickleball, something that still encourages conversation but also gets lets your own energy move around
My friend bri also says to avoid having a table in between you guys as that subconsciously but also literally puts up a barrier, so keep that in mind too
And this next piece of advice is more for my ladies listening but drive yourself to the date, a stranger shouldn’t know where you live because you don’t know who this person could actually be
From a dating standpoint, this is a stranger you can’t expect yourself to know immediately whether this person is worth pursuing after one date
Obviously if that date was awful and the energy wasn’t there, the other person was rude or whatever the case may be, then yeah you know not go on another date
But if you come out of that date and think hmm that was fun, the conversation was good, I still don’t know how I feel about him or her, then go on another date
If there was no blaring red flag, give the other person another chance so you can get to know them better
Afterall, the first date is typically surface level topics and you can’t truly get to know someone within the first 60 minutes of ever meeting them
Think about your friendships, did you become instant besties the first time you ever met them or did it take a couple tries to establish trust and like for them?
My guess is it’s the ladder
Even my current best friend took a few times of being together before I fully was like yeah I want to be around this person more often
The bottomline is, online dating is not natural, I don’t care who you are, it is not a natural way for two people to know each other
Back in the olden days people met each other through friends or coworkers and already had some level of trust and referral established because of the mutual connection
Online dating is two strangers from the internet coming together to see if they are compatible or not
And to repeat, if you’re unsure then you need to stay in that place of curiosity and go on another date with them
Another major part of online dating is knowing why you’re creating this profile
Is it to get a lot of compliments about how attractive you are
Is it to find a long term companion
Is it to sleep around
Regardless of why you’re choosing to create your profile, you need to be very clear and communicative about what you’re looking for
I know bumble lets you put what you’re looking for in your profile whether it be not sure yet, long term relationship, dating, etc
But creating a profile just for a confidence boost and have no intention to ever go on these dates is misleading and discouraging to the person on the receiving end
Because yes there are real people on the other end of this app
And on that note, don’t match with someone you’re never going to message
I personally only swipe right if I know I would message this person and I actually unmatch with them if I change my mind
Because you could feel one way one minute and the next another minute and that’s okay, but it is on you to do the due diligence and not give the other person false hope
Oh and this one is for my girls, spoken directly from a guys mouth, it’s okay to message them first
They don’t read into it like you do
Girls have this belief that you shouldn’t message the guy first, they should make all the first moves, and I’m here to tell you that’s a bunch of hocus pocus
I do believe the guy should plan the first date at least to some extent, but you can definitely message him first
In fact, it’ll help you stand out amongst the crowd and show your confidence in yourself by doing so because most other women will not take that initiative
Yes, bumble promotes the girls to message first, but like I said at the beginning of this episode, even that has changed
As far as how to create a good dating profile goes, I want to remind you that you want to put your best self forward
I’ve come across guys profiles that are like “i play way too many video games” or “I drink too much” like come on leave some room for mystery
While yes, it’s good to tell your potential partner your not so great qualities ahead of time and not let them find out on their own 6 months later, you’re not even letting them get to know you beyond your bad side
It’s as though you’re laying it all out in the open like yup this is me take it or leave, when in reality you wouldn’t tell someone you just met all of your issues and potential red flags
Your dating profile is your first impression, as awful as that sounds
And it’s the first date that determines vibe or chemistry or compatibility, but you’re not even giving yourself a fighting chance to get to the first date when you share a bit too much or even not enough on your profile
On the flip side, helpful things to include on your profile that are important for a potential mate to know ahead of time include if you have kids, or if you’re very religious and are looking for the same, that way it saves you both time and energy if you don’t align on some very important things
I know for me I only swipe right on people who do not have the word faith in their bio or if they put that they drink sometimes or never
And will swipe left if most of their pictures include drinking and partying and this is because I don’t really drink a lot and am looking for someone who has more in their life than alcohol and who isn’t fully wrapped up in their religion because we don’t share the same religion and I’m not very religious
I live in the bible belt so it is a majority of guys who are very faith based which is okay to be, it’s just not what I’m looking for
I also don’t swipe right on a guy who has a child simply because I am not at that point in my life to include children
So when you go to create your profile, you want to show who you are at your best, a glimpse into your personal life like with friends or family, a story that shows a little personality, and a way for someone to engage in a conversation with you
You could have a prompted question or even place on in your bio that opens to the door for someone to easily start messaging you
Also, make sure your pictures are clear and without sunglasses or a hat on in every picture, and smile in your pictures
Guys tend to have blurry hiding pictures and I’m not swiping right on someone I can’t see because how will I even be able to find you in a public setting if we’ve never met before
And another thing is you need solo pictures
If all of your photos are with a group of friends, or even your first two photos and I have to scroll to try to figure out which one is actually the guy behind the profile, then I’m not swiping right
Don’t leave someone guessing, we’re already on edge with the whole dating app in the first place
Try your hardest to make your profile clear, concise, and welcoming
Like I said, this is your first impression
Whereas in the real world, or the wild as I like to call it, first impressions are based off of energy, personality, body language, and mutual interests since you’re at the same place at the same time, but all of that is nonexistent on a dating app
So come in on a strong note while also accurately representing who you are to the best of your ability
And do not ask for someone’s snapchat, snapchat is outdated and immature and frankly a red flag
Literally as I’m creating this episode, I was conversing with a guy on bumble and the conversation went nowhere which is fine, there was nothing to banter with or question asking on his end
But after two days of not having a back and forth he randomly messages me: add me on snapchat at Jonnyboy with some numbers
I screenshotted it and sent it to my friend and said tell me you’re a red flag without telling me you’re a red flag
It’s inappropriate for someone in their late twenties early thirties to be asking for a females snapchat
Besides, I don’t have snapchat anymore and if someone asks for mine, it really shows me where their maturity is at
You should not be asking for someone’s snapchat when you’ve never met them and don’t even have a phone number for, we’re not in high school or college anymore
Find a new tactic to get to know a girl.. I know some of yall have been catfished and snapchat gives you real time pictures of someone, but you know what else gives you a real time visual? Asking a girl on a date
It could be a walking date so you don’t even have to spend a ton of money and feel like it was a waste of money if the date doesn’t go well
The bottomline is, I know the dating apps are god awful, I know that those of you who have found success recognize that it was a diamond in the rough, and I know that with every swipe left your hope for finding a potential mate declines
Dating apps are like a canon event in your twenties, if you didn’t get your MRS degree in college or stick with your highschool sweetheart, we’ve all been on them at one point or another
And I think the most important part of having a dating app, and a first for me with this go around, is downloading them when you are mentally healthy
In the past I’ve had an account because I was desperate for attention or needed a distraction
I’ve also downloaded them to go to new places and meet new people when in first moved to orlando and to charlotte
Yes, I downloaded bumble off of a sunday scary thought post bad, friendzoned coffee date, but I really thought about this download and about where I was at in my life, in my healing journey, in my business, and felt I was in a good place to take this app seriously
And actually, i downloaded, was asked to create a bio, felt overwhelmed by this simple open ended question and immediately deleted the app
Then I played two hours of sports, came home and redownloaded it while texting my friend to help me create it so I wouldn’t back out again
Dating apps are emotionally taxing, they are frustrating, they feel like a never ending pit of unsuitable bachelors, so know that it’s okay to take a break from them when you are feeling negative emotions towards the app
But have the right mindset going into it, take care of your own mental health, be up front with what you’re looking for, set goals around creating the profile or using the app, and be open and safe when online goes to offline and in person
And, probably most importantly, effectively communicate and be respectful to the other person
If you’re not feeling it, say so, don’t ghost them, practice good communication skills and they’ll appreciate you for it
Maybe not in the moment, but think about it on your end, if you got ghosted with someone you wanted to get to know you would feel defeated or hung up on that person as there was no closure
So don’t do that to someone else, we’re adults now, and it’s time you start acting like one
And on that topic of ghosting, know that rejection of the process
My friend bri loves to say rejection is redirection
Don’t let a no get you down, because one more no is bringing you that much closure to a yes
And besides, you cannot say or do the wrong thing to the right person, so if someone doesn’t like you, or if you’re afraid of messaging them or of feeling too needy and they break things off, thank them for not wasting your time
Your person is out there, I promise, at least that’s what I say to myself to get me through these god awful profiles of men
And the last thing I’ll leave you with, is celebrate and acknowledge the successful moments
When a date moves to a second one, or you didn’t walk away from a date thinking that was terrible, or you got off the apps and went on a freakin date
But those are all of my dating app or i guess dating in general cliches for you
Dating in 2024 is tough, i’m not going to sugarcoat it
Dating in your twenties is tough, but it’s not impossible
And if you hate the apps, then get off of them and go to real events or places in person and talk to someone there
I straight up told my therapist I would rather go up to every stranger I find attractive and tell them so, than to be on this dating app
But my introverted ass would panic every time so we continue to swipe and hope that it’ll lead to something
Whether that something is a future boyfriend, a future client, a future friend, or a connection to an opportunity
Because you never know what could come from meeting someone new
And that’s how I’m going to end this episode
Online dating is mentally taxing, but you got this, I got this too, and if you liked this episode, if you were like oh my god jess you were spot on with the world online dating, then please share it, give me five star rating, like and subscribe to stay up to date, email me about your online dating experiences
And as always thank you for listening to another episode of how to twenty-something, I can’t wait to be in your headphones again next week with another brand new episode